It must needs be done, ye,
The Pierats walked away with the prize for their stunning Key Lime Pie, though I must say that the competition was close and the pies were all quite good. I will attempt to recapture the tenor of my note, though the original scoresheets from the event were destroyed lest one find them and go mad.
Here they are
1. not yer Granny's coconot cream rum mud pie
Okay, so this pie was pretty good and had a lot of elements going on. It was pretty ambitious, coconut cream, merangue topping, brownie/black bottom rum crust. The flavors were melding, it was really lovely, but it failed to deliver on consistency. It was pretty much an icebox pie that was begining to liquefy.
2. Key lime pie
If you like key lime pie this was probably your deal. The flavor of this pie was like... if you had a metal teenage daughter and agreed to go to her band's first gig at the Dixie Taverne, and it's Monday night and you've just gotten out of work and then her band starts playing something and she's screaming about how life is a piece of shit and she's going to burn the house down and there's some guy slam dancing next to you and he's just elbowed you in the teeth.
3. Lulabelle:
This pie was cover with fresh raspberries and pansies. The crust was fantastic and studded with bits of pistachio. The filling was perfect, but saddly meshed oddly with the custard filling. Otherwise utterly perfect in every way as a dessert pie. Not too sweet not too bland. Lovely.
This pie is wonderful, but unfortunately this pie is like the upstanding and beautiful girlfriend whose heart will softly be broken when she realizes that I have secretly been sneaking out to make it with the Maytag Blue tart. I will feel bad but dive on midnight highways and split a bottles of cheap booze with the Maytag Blue tart. Lulabelle, she'll wake up alone wondering where I am. I want to be better for the Lulabelle pie, I'll make promises I can't keep, tell her I'll get a better job and we'll move away from this stupid town...
4. blueberry lemon chess pie
5. sweet potatoe pie
I will not comment upon 5&6.
6. Maytag Blue and Asian Pear:
Sister Brother secret lover... Even remembering this pie approaches pornography. This pie is like ripping your clothes off in the middle of the forest, running naked and screaming obscenities and prayer for so long and so hard that your throat becomes hoarse.